Customer Rating:  
Summary: Too Bad I Read The Book First
Comment: If I had seen it before reading the book I might have been able to appreciate it for the movie that it is. However, it takes such liberties with the story it is based on that my students said if it weren't for the title it would be unrecognizable as the same story. Both they and I were very disappointed. The book is fabulous, why couldn't they just have let it be?
Customer Rating:
Summary: A different story
Comment: Rather different from the book, missing several key points that are utterly replaced by others... But a good movie with a good point and still useful for Compare/Contrast assignments for my students.
Customer Rating:
Summary: impressive
Comment: I was impressed and pleased with the speed of delivery and the quality of the product.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Not your typical slave plantation plot
Comment: This was pretty original, considering how Night John looked out for fellow slaves, teaching them to read and so forth. Most runaway slaves don't return to look out for others. He considered being able to read a valuable jewel and wanted to share it. However, I give it 4 stars because it could have been a tad bit more suspenseful.
The little girl was adorable and brave. I respected her strength. No foul language, illicit sex scenes. Good entertainment/education for the kids.
Yes, I would recommend it, especially as a middle school movie day reommendation. If places other than Virginia allow children to recommend movies for history class.
Good job!
Customer Rating:
Summary: Beautiful!
Comment: I showed this moving to my middle school students and they were very captivated by the story. Although the movie doesn't exactly follow the book, it is a strong story that conveys the harsh cruelty of the slavery era without excessive violence. It is intense in parts and I recommend adult supervision and discussion.
|
