| |
Nabaza.net-The MarketPlace - She Stole My Voice: A Documentary About Lesbian Rape (Uncensored Version)
|
List Price: $19.99
Our Price: $17.99
Your Save: $ 2.00 ( 10% )
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
Manufacturer: The American Academy for Film and Gender Studies
Directed By: Justine Chang
|
Average Customer Rating:   
|
|
Audience Rating: NC-17
Binding: DVD
EAN: 0837101429368
Format: NTSC
Label: The American Academy for Film and Gender Studies
Manufacturer: The American Academy for Film and Gender Studies
Number Of Items: 1
Publisher: The American Academy for Film and Gender Studies
Region Code: 1
Release Date: 2007-11-07
Running Time: 88
Studio: The American Academy for Film and Gender Studies
|
|
|
|
|
|
Editorial Reviews:
|
|
In one of the most important and controversial documentaries of the last five years, filmmakers Justine Chang and Armand Kaye examine a crime that has been ignored, discounted, and even declared impossible. The result of years of research and production, She Stole My Voice: A Documentary About Lesbian Rape is a jarring, terrifying, and eye-opening look at this lesbian rape and sexual violence between women. The film masterfully interweaves community responses, expert analyses, and graphic reenactments to create an absolutely unforgettable experience. Viewers will see the reality and prevalence of this crime, and learn how the community as a whole, law enforcement, and even the lesbian community itself have repeatedly discounted this crime. And in the unforgettable and terrifyingly graphic reenactments of lesbian rape, viewers will begin to truly understand the chilling and horrific experience of actual lesbian rape.
|
|
|
Spotlight customer reviews:
|
Customer Rating:
Summary: Brave and honest
Comment: I had seen this documentary on youtube and I had tried to purchase it for some time, when I finally found it on amazon.com, and upon actually seeing it, I was most impressed. I have seen many of the other reviews of this documentary, and the hostile nature of most of them calling it pornographic or disappointing or baulking at it in some other way, are either a), men who just don't get it and never will and don't want to accept that women are capable of these things too, yet they don't seem to hide from it when it's their wives or girlfriends abusing them, b), women who don't want to accept it.
It's so easy isn't it to laugh or critisize. To make a documentary like this takes guts and a real determination to get the truth heard. Of course lesbian rape happens, just like homosexual rape happens in the male community in prisons for example. What makes this so worthy of critism for telling the other side of it? I am hoping to publish a book which attacks women, which critisizes their attitudes in modern society, which may never see the light of day because no one wants to hear it, and so I have to admire this documentary and the makers not only for having the guts to make it in the first place, but for the quality of it too. I was always aware of the darker side of women unfortunately, and it made me laugh when a lot of these victims said they didn't think women were capable of such things. Well they are. And pregnancy is the most vindictive weapon that women can use against them, and they get away with it every time.
I say well done indeed to the makers for being Brave and honest. It's just a pity that we live in a world which likes to hide from these things and slag off what it doesn't understand.
Customer Rating:
Summary: IT COULDVE BEEN BETTER
Comment: I DO UNDERSTAND THE SERIOUSNESS OF LESBIAN RAPE AND I DO AGREE THAT RAPE IS RAPE, BE IT A MALE OR FEMALE RAPIST. THE DOCUMENTARY DOES POINT THAT OUT CLEARLY AND GIVES REASONS WHY ONE SHOULD THINK SO. I'VE ALWAYS SAID TO MYSELF...IF SOMEONE PERFORMS ORAL SEX ON AN UNDER-AGED MINOR, THOUGH HE/SHE DID NOT GET PENETRATED, THE SEXUAL ACT STILL AMOUNTS TO RAPE.
HOWEVER, I DID NOT THINK THAT THE FILM DROVE THE MESSAGE HOME. DON'T GET ME WRONG, IM NOT SAYING THAT THEY DID NOT WORK HARD IN PUTTING THE FILM TOGETHER. WHAT IM SAYING IS THAT THE STORY LINES ARE ALL MESSED UP. IN OTHER WORDS, THEY JUST DON'T MAKE SENSE. SOME OF THE SCENES WERE INDEED GRAPHIC AND AT TIMES HUMILIATING AS I PICTURED MYSELF AND HOW I WOULD NOT WANT A WOMAN WITH A STRAP ON FORCING IT INTO MY MOUTH...AND AT OTHER TIMES, I HAD TO REWIND IT A COUPLE OF TIMES TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT IN THE WORLD WAS GOING ON.
I BOUGHT THIS VIDEO ONLY BECAUSE I DO PARTICIPATE IN A JAIL MINISTRY AND WANTED TO KNOW SECOND HAND WHAT CHALLENGES THEY MAY BE FACING SO I MAY KNOW HOW TO DEAL WITH INMATES ACCORDINGLY. WELL...THAT WENT THOUGHT HE DOOR. I WORK FOR THE GOVERNMENT AND IT'S OBVIOUS TO ME THAT I'M IN THE WRONG BUSINESS. MAYBE I SHOULD BE INTO MARKETING OR SOMETHING.
APPARENTLY THAT'S WHERE ALL THE MONEY IS. WHOEVER MARKETED THIS INDEPENDENT FILM MUST HAVE HELPED THE SCRIPT WRITERS MAKE A KILLING. SAD TO SAY THAT THEY CAUGHT ME. THE WAY THAT THE WRITERS PORTRAYED THE FILM TO BE WAS NOT HOW IT CAME ACROSS.THE BOX THAT IT CAME IN SAID THAT IT IS "AN IMPORTANT STEP FORWARD FOR GAY AND LESBIAN EQUALITY." YES, IT IS, BUT THE ONLY WAY THAT I SEE IT WINNING "BEST DOCUMENTARY" FROM THE GLOBAL INDEPENDENT FILM SHOWCASE IS IF THERE WAS ONLY ONE CHOICE.
FROM LOOKING AT ALL THE PREVIEWS AND OTHER SUPPORTING MEDIA ADVERTISED COMPARED TO WHAT I PURCHASED, COMING FROM A WOMAN WHO LOVES DOCUMENTARIES AND KNOWLEDGE, I PERSONALLY DON'T THINK THAT IT'S WORTH THE BUY.
Customer Rating:
Summary: A brilliant horrible joke a la Andy Kaufman
Comment: This movie is a brilliant horrible joke. Whoever made this film is laughing so hard at us that they will not stop laughing for a long time. On one hand the documentary seems to deal with a serious matter, such as lesbian rape. Most people who are interviewed seem to talk about the theme in a believable way. The testimonials seem believable too, on the surface. The narrator of the documentary, the explanations she gives us are believable. The text scrolling down on the screen about the fact that women can be rapists sounds believable to me, too. On the other hand, the alleged documentary has porn-like reenactments of sexual abuse between women with would-be porn actresses paid to stage lesbian rape scenes for the shock, amazement and perhaps pleasure of the viewers. Why do I call this a "brilliant horrible joke"? I call it "brilliant" because the filmmakers have achieved what they sought for. This is a kind of Andy Kaufman's joke. (Have you watched the movie about this comedian starring Jim Carrey? If you haven't, go watch "Man on the Moon" and you'll see what I mean!) Andy Kaufman was a comedian who relished in pulling practical jokes on everybody: family, friends, girlfriends, you name it. The kind of practical joke Andy liked to pull was to act as though he was serious about something outrageous and horrible when in fact that was all an inside joke. When his family was told he had cancer and he was dying nobody believed him, because they thought he was pulling another practical joke. I view this documentary as a big practical joke. I am sure this was a concept of one person or a group of friends, who decided: "Hey, let's make a seemingly serious documentary about something as outrageous as lesbian rape, something on the edge of believability, and then for the hell of it we will insert staged porn scenes about the same theme. Let's see how many people we will be able to fool and outrage. Let's see if someone will see for what this really is: a big practical joke, which is going to make us rich." And guess what, the filmmakers did just that, as at the moment this practical joke is a huge success in sales. What was supposed to be just a practical joke, became so much more. It became a brilliant marketing strategy to sell a porn DVD to people who wouldn't watch porn. Even better, with the buzz that this (probably unintended) marketing strategy created, they turned a run-of-the-mill rape fantasy porn DVD into something that is making them extremely rich while the filmmakers laugh their way to the bank.
Customer Rating:
Summary: A film of questionable intent
Comment: I'm trying to decide if this is a serious inquiry or an excuse for some unskillful porn. While there is one interviewee who gives the impression of knowing her stuff, The others seem pointedly uninformed, naive, or somewhat inarticulate on the subject. Much of the film consists of interviews, interspersed with very graphic, though quite unbelievable scenes of forced sex between women. No one puts up much of a struggle. No one cries out for help. No one seems to resist very much, except for some squeaky protests worthy of an S&M site. Submission seems to be the order of the day. The cinematography and composition of the dramatized sequences are chaotic, with 'way too much onscreen. One sequence consists of two, count 'em, two rapes in inset boxes, a background that consists of yet another rape in progress, and a long title crawl in the bottom half of the screen, which is yet another rape tale in text. So, what are we supposed to look at? It makes George Lucas look leisurely!
So... I'm trying to decide whether this is an attempt at a scholarly framing device for porn, or if the creators actually believe they've contributed something to a high level communication about an issue they claim to be extremely widespread. I've known plenty of people in "the life," and have never heard anything to support their statistic that 30 per cent of lesbians have been sexually assaulted by a person not their partner.
There is one other thing I found quite disturbing; a general demeaning of male sexuality reminiscent of the most strident feminism of the 1970's. It's out of date, ladies. Male sexuality does not seek to "wound." Your association of popular words for sex (nail, screw, etc.) with harmful intention is your own problem. There are indeed loving and devoted men. Perhaps if you get your mind out of victim mentality, you have a chance to portray important issues in a way that doesn't present women as the wounded prey of implacable sadists. All of your graphic depictions of sex simply placed a woman in the role of a pathological man, popping out of the shadows and doing their dirty work. Perhaps you meant well. Perhaps it was a cynical excuse to sell some uninspired sex footage. If the issue is indeed this widespread, it deserved a higher level of integrity, as well as more competent production values.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Horrible documentary
Comment: I wish I would have known there were reviews of this movie before I purchased it. Hoping to be informed on a subject that deserves attention, I was "treated" to poor reenactments with horrible actresses that only degraded the validity of the film. The film was poorly edited and how the information was presented lacked sophistication and polish. I wish more time was given to presenting scholarly information than the reenacted sex scenes. I don't need to see a rape to believe it exists.
|
|
|
|
|
|
| | |
